Eye Pencils: Everything You Need to Know for Standout Eyes
Using an eye pencil for eye make-up is one of those beauty skills that rarely goes right first time. Yet it is often the easiest tool for transforming your eyes in seconds, once you know which one to pick. With creamy kohls, precise eyeliners and coloured eyeshadow pencils all promising to bring out your best eyes, the choice can feel overwhelming.
Why are there so many types of eye pencil?
Each type of pencil meets a specific need. Intense black kohl defines, white pencil makes the eyes look bigger, waterproof eyeliner lasts all day, and an eyeshadow pencil creates a smoky eye...
Our brands, Yves Saint Laurent, Lancôme, Guerlain, Clarins, Clinique, Sisley and Annayake, each develop their own formulas and applicators. Some focus on long wear, others on a soft application or intense pigment. This variety is not just marketing: it reflects real technical differences that make all the difference in everyday use.
Whether you are looking for your first eye pencil or want to add to your make-up bag, we are here to guide you towards the one that suits you best. Because well-defined eyes can change your whole day.
Our Eye Pencil Products
20 products
Find out more
Kohl, eyeliner, eyeshadow pencil: the main types explained
Kohl remains the most versatile. Its creamy texture goes anywhere: on the waterline to intensify, around the eye to define, or smudged into a soft smoky look. It is often recommended for beginners because it forgives small slips. Current formulas are better than the kohls of the past, without that annoying tendency to migrate under the eye.
A pencil eyeliner is firmer and needs a more precise hand, but it gives a sharp line that stays put. It is the ally of winged eyeliner and graphic lines. At Lancôme or YSL, the tips are shaped to glide without dragging, even on the most sensitive eyelids. The eyeshadow pencil is made for colour: its powdery textures blend easily and let you create gradients with no harsh edges.
How to do your eye make-up according to your eye shape
Round eyes are lengthened with a line that extends slightly past the outer corner. Avoid ringing the whole eye, as this risks making it look smaller. Almond eyes can take almost anything, but it is best to go for intensity rather than tricks. Downturned eyes are lifted with an upward line that starts at the outer third of the eye, never following the natural line of the lid.
With age, an eye pencil becomes even more important than before. Softer textures are preferable (Clarins or Guerlain kohls are perfect for this), and very dark colours that harden the eyes are best avoided. Chocolate brown or taupe warms the look more than a strong black. And to lift the eyes, nothing beats a dot of pearly white pencil at the inner corner.
The technical criteria that make all the difference
The difference between a cheap pencil and a premium one is not only visible on the price tag. First, the lead: high-end pencils contain more pigment and fewer fillers, which gives more intense colour in a single stroke. Then, the texture: good formulas glide without pulling on the delicate skin of the eyelids, which is crucial given how often we blink every day.
Wear depends mainly on the formula. Waterproof pencils (such as those from Clinique) resist water but need a specific make-up remover. Classic long-wear pencils are not waterproof, which makes them more practical day to day. As for retractable versus sharpenable pencils, it is mostly a matter of habit, although retractable ones keep a more even tip.
Current trends and new textures
The market is moving towards more comfortable application. The newest generations of pencils, such as the latest from Sisley, include skincare ingredients (peptides, vitamin E) that look after the fragile eye contour area while you make up. This matters more than it might seem when you wear a pencil every day.
As for colours, absolute black is losing ground to warm browns and coloured greys, which flatter most skin tones. Metallic finishes (bronze, copper, shimmering taupe) are a good way to update a classic look without going over the top. Even white pencils are no longer used only to brighten the waterline: the new pearly nude shades from Annayake or Lancôme give a more natural result that is just as effective.
Frequently asked questions
Kohl has a creamy texture that forgives slips and can be applied anywhere, even on the waterline, and smudged into a smoky effect. A pencil eyeliner is firmer and more precise, ideal for sharp, graphic lines that stay put once applied. Kohl suits beginners better, while eyeliner needs a steadier hand.
For round eyes, the trick is to lengthen the eye with a line that extends slightly past the outer corner. Avoid ringing the whole eye, as this would visually make it look smaller. The aim is to create an illusion of horizontal stretch rather than emphasise the natural roundness.
With age, creamy textures such as kohls are preferable, as they glide better over less smooth eyelids. Soft colours such as chocolate brown or taupe warm the eyes more than a strong black, which can harden the features. A dot of pearly white pencil at the inner corner also helps to visually lift the eyes.
An eyeshadow pencil has a powdery texture that blends easily and lets you create coloured gradients with no visible edges. Unlike kohl or eyeliner, which are used to draw and define, it works as a base for smoky eyes and colour effects across the whole mobile lid.
For downturned eyes, draw an upward line that starts at the outer third of the eye and sweeps up towards the temple. The mistake to avoid is following the natural line of the lid, which would accentuate the downturned effect. This lifted line creates the illusion of a more open, lively eye.